Maharashtra and Jharkhand :: The falling grace of the “ BJP ” and the lessons to be learned


Election as they say- COMES AND GOES. Election as they believe is – SERVES ANOTHER CHACE TO PERFECT THE FLAW TO WIN. However that they do not know -  ELECTIONS ARE THE ONLY PLACE WHERE YOU GET A CHANCE TO DEMONSTRATE THE BEST OF YOUR INTEELIGENCE AND INTELLIGENT TO FINISH YOUR OPPONENT IN ONE GO AND ONE SHOT.

The national scenario of every election may be the same with different ideas used to fight the elections by the different parties .  The focus could be the same but the ideas and the strategies could be different by the different parties to win the seat as much as possible to lay their claim on the throne of the country to rule the country.

The State elections are now-a-days fought in different manner as the issues and the problems of the states are very different. The issues that surmount the centre might NOT be the necessary issue for the state .The state affairs are more FLUID in comparison to the centre and the centre in many a manners would not find the state resonating to the the flux that at times glow and at time dims the centre to apply them as the issues to pull of a scorcher in any way.

The two state election that the BJP , I would say lost their grip on the state of Jharkhand and Maharashtra are the two anti-podes of the affair and a lot comes out of the same when one dissects the reason as to why the BJP went that bad in losing that.

The BJP could have easily helped them at both the state to keep it’s wheel moving towards another five years of it’s rule at the state at these places but the SHORT SIGHTEDNESS of the BJP dug them and GRAVED it to  the deep point of falacity . The opponent could play it’s card well to keep itself afloat

MAHARASHTRA  :: WRONG READING BY THE BJP AND EXCELLENT GAME PLAN BY SHIV SENA

Let us first study and analyse about the so called the YOUNGER BROTHER of the BJP which believes in HARD CORE HINDUTVA and their brilliant card play to keep themselves afloat and prevent itself shrinking




It is a FACT that the Shiv Sena was looking upto the BJP to join them at Maharashtra to completely topple the Congress at the state. Single handedly Raj Thakeray at the deepest root of the state was all at fire implementing the ideas of the late Bala Sahab Thakeray to oust the Congress from the state but the results were not coming.It was because at the state level the people were getting all about the Shiv Sena that it had with it as a national plan for Maharashtra but the lateral aid of the centre was not seen much. Inspite of the various facts and the TACTS that the Late Bala Sahab was drawing for the BJP nothing was at sight and nothing was coming out for the Shiv Sena . It was here that the Shiv Sena opened it’s  “ ARMS ” for another such similar thinking partner and they got the BJOP as their most SUBTLE and TRUSTED ally.  The combination of the BJP-SENA also made it’s way to the power for FIVE YEARS. The BJP remained at the place where the partner is on the run.The driving partner on the driving seat was Shiv Sena

 Initially for about TWENTY years the BJP had to remain at the next rung of this partnership but this scenario started changing since 2013 when it was assumed at large that Mr Narendra Modi would be the one to take it for the BJP next and the people started shifting their allegiance of the vote from the Shiv Sena to the BJP .

Fighting together and sharing the seat for the fight slowly from 2013 started completely to shrink the other political parties at Maharashtra and in the two Lok Sabha election the opposition to the BJP-Sena just could not even see their score microscopically even after using a microscope .That was the state of the affair of both the parties . The result of the 2014 election at Maharashtra completely changed the scenario for the BJP. It not only started getting the major share of the votes at the states but it also started shrinking the Shiv Sena  as well . So much so that in the elections thereafter the scenario became such that the BJP I itself started compiling over 120 seats all by it’s own and the Sainiks were going down

RELATIONSHIP : SAINIK’S ALWAYS A THORN IN THE NECK OF “ BJP ”

The Sainik even if they were the partners of the BJP, they always wee the THORN in the NERCK of the BJP.It was on many an occasion diffused straight and to the point by the Late Bala sahib when he was alive but after his death this became a harsh PAIN for the BJP to always swallow. There were many occasion where the BJP felt to take a strong step but the internal FRIENDSHIP at the state level that the leaders of both the parties had and their personal relationship made the centre to rethink on the same to keep the partnership at float and the sail to be effective , smooth and safe . However the overall condition at the ground level could not be put into the place

When the late Mr Bala Sahab was alive ONE ROAR from his MOUTH like a LION roaring would completely neutralize the situation and the peace would fall into the place but after his death Mr Uddhav Thakeray could not do that with such an ease that Bala Sahabji would do it .The fresult is that the condition started becoming inpalatable for both the parties to be even and there arrived a point when the Sainik’s came ot of the Ministership at the centre and came out of the union ship to run the Government at the state but it did not withdraw it’s support from either the centre or the state .It kept on supporting the BJP to run the Government in term of it’s governance and the Government at the state

ELECTION 2019 & the State election : BRILLIANT SAINIK’S PLAY THEIR GAME TO KEEP THEMSELVES AFLOAT

One of the MOST IMPORTANT card that the Sainik played in the Lok Sabha election was that they agreed to share the seats at the state for the Lok Sabha election.This they knew would be to  their advantage because the NAME and the BRAND “ MODI ” would get them the juice and the morrow  to energise them to remain a POTENT force at the state . That they did it efficiently to keep their slate clean and intact. The name MODI brought them the votes from the corner as well where the people did not want them to be voted for. This was a BRILLIANT ploy employed by the Sainik’s HAT’S OFF TO THEIR MASTERMIND FOR THE SAME

However when they parted the ways with the BJP at the state by pulling out of the Government but supporting them from outside their vote share started plummeting and it got uprooted the most The Sainiks thereafter in the local elections from the ward level to the other level of elections started losing their seats like anything in all the places of Maharashtra.This made them to rethink and in the last state election they were FAST and QUICK to realize that without the amalgamation of their partner which has such a huge presence at the centre, they would not be able to  cut the line and draw the boundaries for themselves. HERE IS WHERE THE  “ BJP ” AND IT’S CENTRE LEADTRSHIP FAILED TO READ THE MOMEMTUM THAT THEY HAD WITH THEM AND THE  “ SAINIK’S ” could read it by their palms

 BHUPENDRA YADAV : A “USELESS ” BJP LEADER HOLDING NIETHER THE CARDS NOR A “ TRUMP ”



The glaring mistake that the BJP right from the inception of this state election of Maharashtra was the selected Bhupendra Yadav  WHO ACTUALLY WOULD FIND NO STREAM TO FLOW AT MAHARASHTRA WHERE THERE IS A SAINIK CANAL DRAWN. These kind of useless and MINDLESS politicians wll never be able to PULL anything surprising for their parties.

What does this man knows in PRACTICALITIES and in REALITIES of either the state, or the centre or anything that relates to the EFFICACIES and  INTRICACIES of DEEP-ROOTED- INDIAN –POLITICS that surmounts the root-nook-corner of the voters spread out in the length and breadth of this country . Buttering and pestering the HIGHER ECHELONS of the BJP and managing his pace at the Rajya Sabha this man who appears to be a CALF above is a REAL-HIDING-WOLF in the BJP who has attached himself so closely to Mr Amit Shah that this is the FIRST “ FALL” that Mr Amit Shah and Mr Modi got out of him and if they CONTINUE to put him on their LAP and FEED him with the POOPCEE MILK BOTTLE the TWO HONCHOS of the BJP will have to SUCK their THUMBS rather than seeing the “ THUMS ” .This man Bhupendra Yadav may gloat over the victory of the BJP at places where the BJP leadership is very strong or the BJP and it’s state partner are very strong because of the state partner or else he is a BIG DRUM which beats fast but without any effect because of it’s hollowness .

To be precise the BJP will NOT have to bother at Bihar where the Nitish Babu and it’s factors are so strong that if a DUMBALL like Bhupendra Yadav is put as the OBSERVER-CUM-INCHARGE of the BJP at Bihar Mr Nitish babu will win the election irrespective of the outside factor doing any grace to him to win that  THE ONE’S LIKE THE BHUPENDRA YADAV WILL GET THE CREDIT That is a FAULTY measurement of the success in all .

Bhupendra Yadav might have tasted success at places like Bihar courtesy Mr Nitish Babu but that is NOT at all any measurement of success.He has failed miserably to me a CENTRE OF BALANCE at Maharashtra, he failed mercilessly at Bihar as well . I would not give that Lok Sabha success to him at all where he was the incharge of the Lok Sabha poll. When you have Mr Nitish Kumar you do not have to need anybody as OBSERVER or a SLEEPER at all .This DUMBALL ought to have played his part PERFECTLY advising the BJP to go all alone at the election. Atleast one such REPORT from him should have come to the centre which controls the BJP and it’s election campaign  BUT HE FAILED.He was a PAYING GUEST to Mr Phadnavis enjoying the MOON and the CAKE and the rest is a history

If I were at his place- I WOULD HAVE DEFIED THE LAW TO THE BJP CENTRAL LEADERSHIP TO GO ALL ALONE AT MAHARASHTRA RATHER THAN SEAT SHARING AND AFTER THE REUSLT I WOULD HAVE ADVISED THE BJP TO AMAGAMATE WITH THE SAINIK’S TO FORM THE GOVERNMENT This would have made the BJP to win ablest 130 seats all by alone and the rest could have come in the form of the partner. ALAS AND BUTTHE FALLING GRACE OF Mr BHUPENDRA YADAV THE DUMBALL WHO IS A DUMB TO THE PARTY BUT NOT AL ALL  TO THE HIGHER ECHELON OF THE BJP His MUTE SPECTATORSHIP not only caused the BJP the state but also a REASONABLE partner who is always a THORN in the neck of the BJP but always a HELPING HAND

The other reason for the BJP to loose the battle at Maharashtra was the PERSONAL EGO of Mr Phadnvis and Mr Uddhav Thakeray. Here Mr Bhupendra Yadav FAILED MISERABLY as a MEDIATOR. SIMPLY SITTING AT THE HEAD OFFICE OF THER BJP AND EXTARCTING OUT THE MONEY FROM THE HELPLESS TO ALLOW THEM TO MEET THE HIGHER ECHELON OF THE BJP OR TO SEND THEM PACKING OUT OF THE MAIN OFFICE OF BJP IS NOT LEADERSHIP OR REAL POLITICS

Real politics lies in BALANCING THE PARTNERS and bringing about an UNIFORMITY when there are issues and here again both Mr Bhupendra Yadav and Mr Phadnavis failed. The Sainik’s again were brilliant. Sharing the seats with the BJP they kept their card intact. They knew that without Mr Modi it would not have been possible for them to amass anything worth so during the eelctions they used the cut-out odf Mr Modi like anything to gain as many seats as possible, Thereafter came the moment to share the cake.It is there the BJP again failed to keep it’s cards at the places and play them perfectly. A lot of this has to be placed on Mr Bhupendra Yadav and a little to Mr Phadnavis.

 IF THE BJP HAD GONE ALONE AT MAHARASHTRA BELIEVE ME THEY WOULD HAVE WON ATLEAST 130 SEATS NOT LESS BUT THAT  “ DUMBALL ”   HIS HIGHNESS, Mr BHUPENDRA YADAV. Finally that was that. May I be permitted to say a LAST PHRASE- IF YOU HAVE BHUPENDRA, YOU WILL FACE REALM-                         “ LOOTENDRA ”

JHARKHAND : POOR VISION OF Mr RAGHUVAR DAS AND HOOFING AJSU DUG GRAVE FOR BJP

The two states JHARKHAND and MAHARASHTRA are OPPOSITE and ANTI-PODES to each other At Maharashtra the NATIONAL EXECUTIONEERING will and can play a TRUMP CARD but at Jharkahnd the local issues like the Naxalities, the Local Leader, the Security, the even benefits of the distribution of the local resources and the national resources, the jungle and it’s resources, the adivasis and the tribal problems, tese are the issues that makes a LOT of the things topple the applecart. Over it JHARKHAND is a state where the mini shopping ie DUKAANDAARI and the income from it makes a HELLUVA difference to the lives of the business community and to the people over there. These were not read by the BJP local leadership over there and this was BRILLIANTLY read by Mr Shibu Soren HE WON THE ELECTION ON THIS PLOT



The second mistake was the seat sharing. I SINCERELY SAY-  HAD THE BJP SHARED THE SEAT WITH THE AJSU IT WOULD HAVE WON ATLEAST 33 SEATS AND IT COULD HAVE HELPED THE AJSU TO WIN ATLEAT SEVEN SEATS. Then with the Independent the BJP could have formed the Government at the state The AJSU holds a commanding 8% of the vote share and this could have made a HELLUVA difference to the fortune of the BJP

Looking into their state of affair at Maharashtra they felt like going alone here. This was the mistake they did. At Maharashtra they have and had a partner who were their THORN in the NECK. Here at Jharkhand they had a partner who always had been their ARMS UNDER THE SLEEVES .Here it was that Mr Raghuvar Das got everything wrong and the BJP Central leadership got it wrong

At Maharashtra the tribes and the tribals are HINDU followers. At Jharkhand the TRIBES are the HINDUS but they follow CHRISTIANITY. During the time when Bihar and Jharkhand were not divided the Christian machineries would plunge them in an electrifying manner to convert the Hindus to Chritianities and get the votes for the Congress. However the scenario changed after the JMM came into the picture. The JMM knows how to play it’s card to these tribes irrespective of what they are to garner the votes

The Congress could smell that and gave the lead to the JMM to be the Senior partner and win 16 seats which is their HIGHEST total at Jharkhand . The BJP completely failed , FIRST- to read the situation, SECOND- to read the EFFECTIVENESS of the AJSU as their partner and  THIRD- to go in the polls alone. The vote distribution completely offloaded the BJP and the vote assimilation grounded and founded the REBIRTH of NOT only the JMM but also the Soren’s at the state.THE CONGRESS IS A  BASKET WHICH THE JMM IS CARRYING AND THERE LIES THE DIFFERENCE.

MISTAKE- A MISTAKE FOR ETERNITY FOR BJP BY DISCARDING THE “ YUG-PURUSH ” OF BJP

Infact- IN THE HISTORY OF THE BJP PARTY AS FAR AS IT’S STATE POLITICS IS CONCERNED THERE HAVE BEEN TWO YUGPURUSH AS WE SAY . The FIRST was Mr Dilip Singh Judeo and the second one was Mr Babulal Marandi .At the CENTRE there has been and there will be ONLY ONE- Shri ATAL BEHARI VAJAPAYEE

Jharkhand REALLY needed a MARANDI and Chattisgarh really needed a Dilip Singh Judeo kind of a person to take the BJP ahead and forward with PANACHE  as the CENTRAL LEADER of the state as a BINDING FORCE .The CRIMINAL ploy by the Jogi’s really CRUCIFIED Mr Judeo who id he had been the Chief Minister of Chattisgarh, would have FINISHED the CONGRESS and the JOGI’S FOR EVER and at Jharkhand Mr Marandi would have FINISHED  the Congress , the JMM and the others for all but for the WICKED ploy of that NOTORIUS Mr Jogi and the useless ploy and the act of Mr Rajnath Singh




None other than Mr Vajapayee had termed these two SANGHI’S as the YUGPURUSH of the respective state and IT WAS NOT FOR NOTHING THAT THE STATE UNDER Mr MARANDI AND THE BJP WERE BECOMING  A TERRIFIC  STERNGTH AT JHARKHAND




However the FAULTY ideas of crucification given to Mr Rajnath Singh who was the All India Head of the BJP at the centre-  WE CALL IT “ KAAN-PATLA ”  CHUGLI that it is, Mr Rajnath Singh without looking into the deep end future in ONE GO came to Jharkhand and removed the EVER EFFICIENT Mr Marandi from the state leadership for everything. BELIEVE ME EVER SINCE THEN JHARKHAND NEVER HAD THE BJP WINING BY 505 OF SEAT OR 2/3 MAJORITY which it could do ONCE when Mr Marandi was their State Leader for everything

The way Mr Marandi was HOOFED out and the way he was humiliated and insulted, not only the BJP is at it’s receiving end but it is at it’s wits end too . A Shibu Soren on it’s own winning 30 seats and pushing the BJP into the corner of the ring to punch it is NOT A JOKE BUT AN ALARM and this the BJP has to read fast and fast

It is  again that  the FUTURE of Jharkhand is Mr Babulal Marandi and if the BJP has to come back to it’s own at Jharkahnd it has to bring in Mt Marandi who is a HOUSEHOLD name at Jharkahnd and a YUGPURUSH to all the Jharkahndi’s . No other solution for the BJP remains at Jharkhand

It is Mr Modi who has to take the initiative, He has tpo apply the BALM at the places on the body of Mr Marandi- the way he was HUMILIATED and INSULTED first by seizing his seat and then his position at Jharkhand that the BJP courtesy Mr Modi has to do that to resurge with full aim and  splurge at Jharkahnd to do and to gain it’s lost empire THAT IS THE ONLY SOLUTION FOR THE BJP Also for Mr Marandi- WITH THE BJP YOU CAN MAKE IT FOR ABOUT 10 YEARS IN A ROW. THE CHOICE AND THE DECISION IS YOURS

The CENTRAL LEADERSHIP of the BJP- CHOOSE YOUR MEN PROPERLY AND PLAY YOUR CARD PROPERLY THINK AND RETHINK 100 OF TIMES BEFORE YOU DO TO A STATE LEADER THAT YOU DID IT TO Mr MARANDI  The state elections are NEVER fought on the planks of the centre everywhere and AVIOD listening to the JAICHANDS that you have pampered and  have made your favourite PET’S for everything . Mind You- THESE ARE NOT THE “ MOTHER’S ” PET  but USELESS “ BET ”

That is it

Regards

Shyamal Bhattacharjee













Comments