" FAILURES BRINGS DISSAPOINMENTS-AGREED, BUT NOT EVEN TRYING THEM BRINGS DISASTER AND AN END ".




Pic - :; The Caricature Of The State Of Bengal Being hanged 

" FAILURES BRINGS DISSAPOINMENTS-AGREED, BUT NOT EVEN TRYING THEM BRINGS DISASTER AND AN END ".

This is all about the Bengal election and the results that we see before our eye. This election was the most fiercely contested election that ever has taken place in the annals of the history of Bengal between the two side, the FIRST is the local side the TMC which is the replicate of the MARXIST-COMMUNIST party and the other was the BJP which is the nationalist party, or a national party.



Pic - : The " PADMA " , ie , the " PODDO " That The State And People Of Bengal Rejected 

There were many factors that went all along in this election and at last there were some culminating factors that went a long way for the Trinamool Marxist Communist party to win this election.

What actually were the factors that went a long way for the BJP to win this election in a way to muster those 75 seats and what were the factors that the BJP was DEMOLISHED in such a telling fashion when they conceded those 213 seats to the BJP, as I write BJP for TMC because the BJP defeated themselves rather than defeating the TMC .The main factors that went a long way in either way are illustrated as under-:

1). The MUSLIM Voters-:

There are about 28% of the Muslim voters in Bengal and it could run upto even more.  The Muslims got their flocks together after Ms mamta Banerjee made a public announcement in one of her rally specially asking them with an urgence and a request to cast their vote in all to the TMC only to keep the BJP out saying that the BJP if it enters Bengal would completely vanquish the state and put it in disorder .

The Muslims in India actually FEAR the BJP because they feel that if the BJP takes over any state in India, they will completely fall onto the Muslim populous to cleanse and clean the state. Undoubtedly most of the anti-ruckus creaters are Muslim with their anti Hindu and pro-fanning poloicy. Most of the one’s are out in open.They get the shelter from the non BJP party .These collect the Muslim votes and put it into the kitty of the party opposite the BJP.  Hence these votes collectors for the opposite the BJP party get respites from the party that they help in winning the elections.

Fearing the lash , once again these cat their votes for the TMC. That percentage of the votes really put the BJP in shambles. BJP was targeting about 56% of the votes from the Hindus which they did not get it as all the Women voters about 38% of them cast their votes in favour of the TMC.It was NOT because of the fact that they really were so impressed my Madam Banerjee, ut the FEAR-PSYCHOSIS  also played it’s part well. After the elections were over the real picture that we still see on the REPUBLIC BANGLA TV is clear as to how and to what an extent the fear psychosis at Bengal rules after the elections are over. THAT MADE A HUGE DIFFEERNCE  with the Women voters cast their votes to the TMC.

The problem that will ever remain with the BJP is the Muslims will NEVER vote for the BJP and the BJP will always try to polarise the Muslim votes by amassing the HINDU VOTE. 

2). The Failure Of The Division Of The Muslim Votes -:

It was expected that the Muslim votes would be divided once after Mr Owaisi and his party entered the fray at Bengal. BJP and the wise minds were of the opinion that the Muslim votes will be parried away by the Owaisi and his associate partners at Bengal. That would dent the TMC . However it did not happen. Sensing the FEAR that if the BJP takes over Bengal, then the OUTLAW that are breathing PEACE at Bengal would be toyed with and taken to the task heavily.  The TWO announcement made by Mr Amit Shah and Mr Yogi Adityanath that after the election on May 2nd after the results were out, if the BJP wins the outlaws would be unearthened from the earth to put them under the law were the sound that always echoed in the ears of the one’s who feared that lash. Specially the Muslim voters assembled to their inner voice and fearing the outlash cast their votes in favour of the TMC completely ignoring the Owaisi and the FURFURA combination. The BJP which  was expecting the division of this vote bank got a JOLT of their attempt to see that the Muslim votes did not get disbursed between the two faction and that went in a long way to the TMC to see their castle intact .

3). The LEFT-COMMUNIST Transfer of the votes to TRINAMOOL-MARXIST-COMMUNIST Party

The TMC cadre is the cadre that they have got in on a plater from the LEFT-MARXIST in 2011. At and in Bengal the LEFT-COMMUNIST had created a cadre that originates from the root at the tiny village and ends up at Kolkatta and is organized in such a manner that every nook and every corner and it’s STATISTICS is in the finger tips of the party ruling the state.

The LEFT-COMMUNIST had spread it’s cadre in such a manner that the HEAD of the CADRE of one NOOK oe one CORNER would have the counts of every household and the votes that ought to come in their kitty. Once Ms mamta Banerjee uprooted the LEFT-COMMUNIST-MAOIST, these cadre had no choice but to come to the FOLD of the TMC.It was evident that they did that because their MONTHLY INCOME came in from the  syndication and the likes of it for survival. One who would uproot that scheme would face a lot of problems and Ms Mamta Banerjee allowed that strong cadre to take the fold and to come under the umbrella of the TMC.Thus it got automatically a very strong cadre .This cadre since 2011 is playing with the idea of toppling the TMC so that the LEFT-COMMUNIST takes over Bengal.

This LEFT-COMMUNIST voters in and on 2019 about 5 to 12 % voted as an experimentation to see what happens if they vote against the TMC, and they voted in favour of the BJP in the 20219 Lok sabha election.  The BJP earned about 18 seats.That made them very strong to believe that the nxt State election could see them toppling the TMC. This was a WRONG calculation on the part of the BJP to take it as a GRANTED vote/voters.

Came the Bengal election and the FIFTH round of the VOTING and the LEFT votes started getting transferred to the TMC only to keep the BJP out of the state of Bengal. That finally saw the waterloo of the BJP and it’s plan.

4). The MMD Sector and it’s votes-:

There at the State of Bengal the MMD ( MALDA- MURSHIDABAD- DINAJPUR) plays a very PIVOTAL role in  deciding which party actually will rule the state.

The Malda area and it’s constituency is completely for the CONGRESS, the Murshidabad is the BASTION and the FORTE of the CONGRESS and the Dinajpur is the place from where the LEFT completely sways and swaps the opponent for it’s vote share.

This is the area where the BJP is too weak, and the BJP did a MIRACLE by winning the MURSHIDABAD constituency but it lost all the other constituency to the Trinomool and it could not do anything better as compared to the 2019 election where it had made a heavy inroads in the Malda and the Dinajpur area , this time.



Pic - :: The Mental State Of The Mind Of The Women/Ladies Voters of Bengal since the  time and the  era of 1977 .

The continuous announcement by Ms Mamta Banerjee in terms of the appeal to cast their votes collectively for the TMC especially to the voters from the ladies/women category and especially to the Muslim voters,   to only keep the BJP out of  the power at Kolkatta and Bengal actually made the voters to cast their vote for the TMC and that made the difference.

5). The END-ROOT-CADRE of the TMC and it’s role

The END ROOT cadre that the TMC has and still has is what the BJP lacked. BJP does NOT possesses an organization like the TMC possesses because of the TRANSFER pf the LEFT-MAOIST-COMMUNIST and it’s cadre/men to the TMC . The TMC cadre is well spread and it has a complete sway for the party at the time of the election.

 This was evident immediately after the fourth round,  when the cadre based leadrrs at the various places wherever thee votes were held started - :

1). A method to take over the polling booths under their control  to change the course of the voting.They found a strong resistance from the Central Commanding Force and were unable to do that.This actually is the voting culture  of the election in Bengal since 1977 when the LEFT-MAOIST-COMMUNIST started to dictate the terms at Bengal .

2). They went from house to house to INTIDIMATE the voters of the BJP to NOT to go to the polling centre/polling booths to cast their vote. The results were seen at Sitlakuchi which is a STRONG TMC bastion and at last which the BJP had won.

3). In the last two rounds of the voting, the voters in full majority at many a place, specially the BJP voters just did NOT come out of the house to go to the polling centre. Polling votes to cast their votes in favour of their party.That made a strong difference to the final outcome of the result.

 6 ). In All About A Crore Of Voters Did Not cast Their Votes-:

The Entire State Of Bengal Has About 6.75 Croes Of Voters . This time around ONE CRORE of the VOTERS which could be the voters of the TMC, the LEFT, the BJP or even the VCongress , did not come out of their house to vote.

To cite an example at nadigram, the total number of voters were about 3.0lakhs, of which only 2.50 lakhs did cast their vote. The others who were about 50,000 voters did not come to cat their vote FEARING the DEATH that loomed large on them.These were the SHUBHENDU ADHIKARI & FAMILY VOTER, and NOT the BJP. They simply kept themselves out of the contention to vote because of the DEATH loomimng large on them after the results were declared.

Had they cast their vote the defeat for Ms  Mamta Banerjee would have been by about 50,000 votes. Even with them not voting , what had happened at Nandigram and what ACTUALLY is going on at Bengal,  is what we saw  and everyday we see, on the REPUBLIC BANGLA .

It is to the DECREE and the BLESSING of the ALMIGHTY that Ms Banerjee is declared a LOSER by about 1959 votes or else the margin would have been 51 , 959 votes .

7). Had Not The Central Commanding Force, It Would Have Been 294/294 for the TMC

It was because and because of the Central Commanding Force that the results were 213 for the TMC and 77 for the BJP. Had NOT it been the Central Commanding  Force  which guarded all the citadel at Bengal, it would have been 294/294 for the TMC , by the manner in which they LOOT the polling centers/polling booth. This practice is there which is prevalent even now, and this practice continues since the 1977 election and it runs even now at Bengal.

UNLESS AND UNTIL THE ENTIRE STATE OF BENGAL IS COVERED BY THE CENTRAL COMMANDING FORCE,  DURING THE ELECTION, THE PARTY RULING THE STATE CANNOT BE DEFEATED

This time around at least the people were somewhat out of their SCARY ZONE for most of the time to franchise their authority without fear for certain period of time and we see the opposition garnering about 77 seats which is a TRILLION- RECORD at Bengal. Bengal since 1954-55 has always been a ALMOST-NIL-OPPOSITION for everytime.

The NEXT ELECTION at Uttar Pradesh too has to be conducted under the watchful eye of the CENTRAL COMMANDING FORCE or else a BLOOD WAR awaist next at Uttar Pradesh.The Bengal string and the THREAD has been taken by the Uttar Pradesh party and this is a CLEAR SIGNAL to the CENTRE- PLEASE TAKE THE COGNISANSE.

7). There Were 92 Centres Where the Diffeernce was 500 To 5000 votes

This election of Bengal will go into the BOOKS of the HISTORY as a MIRACLE.The average VICTORY VOTE garnered was about 37,000 plus about 700 votes . That is what the TMC had garnered .  The average vote garnered by the BJP was about 14,000 plus votes. This is the HIGHEST on an average the losres had garnered. 

NEVER IN THE HISTORY OF BENGAL DID A WINNER GARNER AND DID A LOSER GARNERED TO WIN BY THAT A NUMBER OF VOTES

There were about 92 polling centres where the difference between a VICTOR and a LOSER was about 500 votes to about 5,000 votes. Those were all swapped by the TMC.

Had the voters turned out in full, keeping the FEAR-PSYCHOSIS back at their room or the house and voted with full authority , the results would have been very close in all the matters and that would have made a difference to the fortune of many.

 IT WAS THE NON-ZERO-EXISTING CADRE OF THE BJP AND A HOUSE-FULL-OVERPOPULUS CADRE OF THE LEFT TURNED TMC CADRE THAT MADE THE DIFFEERNCE.

The cadre at he ground and the deepest root level of the TMC and their foreplay is what turned the game in their favour.

 UNLESS AND UNTIL THE BJP MAKES A GROUND CADRE AS STRONG AS THE OPPONENT WITH FULLY ARMED WITH EVERY MEANS OF WEAPON, THE BJP WILL NOT BE ABLE TO WITHSTAND THE FURY OF IT’S OPPONENT IN THE FUTURE AT ALL .

What we see at Bengal after the results were out in open, with their GOONS completely dancing a DEVIL’S DANCE  is the COVER under the UMBRELLA that reins at Bengal which the ruling party possesses as it’s greatest TRUMP CARD to KILL whatever the opponent would have with them for the future, so that in the future, the ruling party does not faces any opposition.

The writings are very clear on the wall. For the panchatay election, for the Munciplaity election and for the 2024 election- THE SCORE CARD OF THE BJP WOULD BE NIL, NIL AND MAYBE SEVEN SEATS ( IF THE TMS GOONS DO NOT DANCE THE DEVIL’S DANCE in 2024).

This was the PLOY of the COMMUNIST-LEFT-MAOIST party since 1982 and this still reins at Bengal.

 The SINGUR ploy and the NANDIGRAM MILK in 2011 which was a  HYPNOTISING MAGIC played by Mamta Banerjee to oust the MAOIST-COMMUNIST-LEFT from the state , and a powerful cadre if at all is not formed by the BJP, which is a very impossible factor, and if that kind of a HYPNOTISE is NOT employed by the BJP, the BJP will not be able to do anything at Bengal  AND THAT IS WHAT THE PEOPLE OF BENGAL WANT.

Simply a Prime Minsiter, a Home Minister, and a ALL INDIA PRESIDENT of the party going to an open field at Bengal with their  CM , ie , CHANGOO-MANGOO and reciting some COUPLETS of Guruvar Tagore, or some lines from and of the Swami Vivekananda will NEVER fetch them anything .

A THORN PULLS OUT THE THORN, THE POISON CUTS OFF THE POISON, THE GLASS CUTS THE GLASS, AND THE SWORDS CUTS OF THE EDGE OF THE SWORD AND EQUALITY MATCHES THE EQUALITY.

Until and unless the BJP moves ahead with this principles, that I have stated above,  and makes it’s cadre and the strength to equalize with and to  their opponent, what we will see is always the AFTERMATH that we see in the Republic Bangla channel after the elections at Bengal.

Mamta Banerjee played her cards well. She knew by her palms the IFF’S and the BUTT’S of Bengal. It is the LOCAL of the BJP which will have to play that game and it is here that Mr Dilip Ghosh will have to be the epi-centre .There lies the future of the BJP at the state else FORGET BENGAL .

“ DIDI-O-DIDI ”  :: Not At All A Negative Factor For The Election

Many have asked me that if the NARRATIVE that I have mentioned here at above  was a deterrent factor at Bengal inthis election

NO-NEVER-NOT-AT-ALL is my answer. Never was this narrative a deterrent factor THOUGH ON A PERSONAL SCALE, I feel that it was stretched too far .That should have evaporated after the second or maybe the third phase of the election.

Bengal wanted a LEAST EVIL party amongst the less evil and the little evil, and they at last found the LEAST evil party in TMC and they voted for it.

Bengalis know very well, from the SAINT to the HORRENDOUS DEVILS that the day the BJP enters this state, the DANCE-OF-THE-DEATH that engrosses the FEAR to live with will be OVER. They are adept to lead their life in the , manner where there is FEAR quite opposite to what Mr Tagore had written-:

 WHERE THE MIND IS WITHOUT FEAR , ………

Fear is the RECIPE which is just like a BEAUTIFUL DRESS that the Bengali’s wear , ie , it is an attire that goes well with the Bengali’s to live with as they have been living in that circumstances since 1977 , and wanted that to have it with them and they got it as they have selected and elected it.

DIDO-O-DIDI has nothing to do with the LOSS of the BJP.

Infact DIDI-O-DIDI , TERI SHAADI JUB HOGI, TU DEKHNA is a song pictured on Jaya Bhaduri, a Bengali in the film NAYA DIN , NAI RAAT , released in 1972 .

Marriage is NOT on the card of Ms Banerjee and hence that SONG will not find a favour in Bengal at all. Obviously the state would not see any NAYA DIN , NAI RAAT and the BJP also will find it very hard to bring that in at Bengal till this Lady - MAVERICK rules the state. .

The POSITIVES and the NEGATIVES of Ms Mamta Banerjee in the last ONE DECADE 

I shall make an overview and a PANORAMIC study of the developement that Bengal has seen i her regime over the last DECADE and leave it for the readers to judge it though I will put on own views as an observer at the end. 

After the 34 year rule of the left, Mamata Banerjee’s ascent to power was like a breath of fresh air for Bengal. And she did start well…

There was a positive swing to the mentality of people. The Left rule had seen bandhs and hartals at a drop of a hat. In Ms Banerjee’s rule that has come down to zero.

Roads are much better now than what WB had seen in the last 30 years. Overall land transport infrastructure like bridges, flyovers, wide footpaths etc was developed. During this rule Bengal has also seen quite a few beautification projects.

Tourism has also got a boost with the tourist spots being better connected by trains and buses and also the tourists places being cleaner than earlier years.

Ms Banerjee has payed special emphasis on developments in agriculture. It is said that ,  vegetables & fruits are now being exported to European countries though one really has to see that. There is no EXPORT PROMOTION COUNCIL either with the State or the Centre having any Office as such . Still it is said that these items are exported. 

Many new govt schemes were launched like the cycles for school children, one time money for marriageable girls etc. The lower middle class and the poor people have benefited to a great extent from these schemes. However it has been the MUSLIM community that has received these GIFTS from their Didi.The Hindus if at all they have their links might have received it but if NOT, then not. 

 So as it goes , But….now comes a BIG BUT… and this to me remains a BUTT of all the JOKES 

On the flip side…the democratic process, law and order especially during the panchayat polls have reached the nadir. The last assembly and panchayat polls saw unprecedented violence by the ruling party against the opposition.

The chit fund scam is a big blot in the reign of Ms Banerjee. The netas & bureaucrats have amassed huge sums from the chit fund scam. Top honchos of the ruling party were imprisoned in relation to the scam. This undiluted corruption at all levels of the ruling party was never seen in the last three decades of Left rule.

The cancer of corruption has spread so much in the ruling party that every other day there are intra party feuds leading to murders which were unheard of earlier.

Moreover the whole administration is skewed towards just one person. The whole state is awash with the posters of Ms Banerjee through out the year and it seems as if the she is the only one person in the administration and it is one man or rather one woman show and no one else matters.

So Bengal has witnessed a mixture of positives and negatives during Ms Banerjee’s reign.

Thanks for the views and upvotes:

I had originally answered the question in around two years ago. And till then there were some good things which had happened in Bengal under Mamata. But the journey from there has been totally downhill.

TMC supremo has done a mockery of democracy by staging a dharna when the CBI came to arrest the then Kolkata CP Rajiv Kumar. She and her party are so in collusion with the CP in matters of Sarada corruption that she just couldn't let the documents fall in the hand of central agencies. Such is the level of corruption she endorses.

No new industry has come to Bengal and the state is witnessing a brain drain. All her hullabaloo about the Bengal Business Summit and hobnobbing with the industry captains is nothing but a sham.

No school service commission exams in the last ten years. Whatever teacher recruitment has happened is through the backdoor only with huge amounts of money going to bhaipo ".  Add to it are the EXPORTS of ILLEGAL faunas maybe HERBIVORUS , maybe CANIVORUS  to Bangladesh. Over it add the cut and the SYNDICATED MONEY that comes to the BHAIPO  through the nexus and the  CAUCUS that he has formed and that with whom he is.  Mamata Banerjee projects an image of simplicity but her family, in the years of her rule, has come to own 35 prime properties in the heart of Kolkata near her residence.

Minority appeasement is another of area where she floundered heavily. She treated Muslim people as vote banks and did not do anything for their overall well being and jobs. She only played the religion card to garner votes. paying them some money to run the Madarsas and helping them by paying them to hold themselves by some CHEAP means of ALMS is all that she has done for the MUSLIMS which is her DOME for vote-bank. 

So overall the negatives far outweigh the positives of Mamata's regime in Bengal.

 CERTAIN THINGS/OBJECT , REMAINS STATIC AND THAT IS THE FUNDAMENTAL RULE OF THE THEORY OF STATICS . For Ms Mamta Banerjee the Muslims and her manner to rule the state in the manner that I have described are the FUNDAMENTAL OF STATICS FOR BENGAL that she follows. 

BJP one might say has FAILED , but it did give a HARD TRY. There is NOTHING to despair. Things at the national level is NOT at all that bad for them.

They need to FIRST conquer the COVID-CORUNA. Then the other would fall into place and my reading is from November things will once again start falling in the GROOVE for the BJP. The nature and it’s SPEWS are against the BJP for the time being ,  but then THIS TOO WILL PASS .  As they say - : 

 EVERY BLESSED DAMN HAS IT’S END.

Regards and Thanks

Pics



Shyamal Bhattacharjee 

Mr Shyamal Bhattacharjee, the author was born at West Chirimiri Colliery at District Surguja, Chattisgarh on July 6th 1959 He received his early education at Carmel Convent School Bishrampur and later at Christ Church Boys' Higher Secondary School at Jabalpur. He later joined Hislop College at Nagpur and completed his graduation in Science and he also added a degree in    B A thereafter. He joined the HITAVADA, a leading dailies of Central India at Nagpur as a      Sub-Editor ( Sports ) but gave up to complete his MBA in 1984 He thereafter added a Diploma In Export Management. He has authored THREE books namely Notable Quotes and Noble Thought published by Pustak Mahal in 2001 Indian Cricket : Faces That Changed It  published by Manas Publications in 2009 and Essential Of Office Management published by NBCA, Kolkatta  in 2012. He has a experience of about 35 years in Marketing .






Signature Of Shyamal Bhattacharjee 

This website is maintained , controlled and managed by OOK’S Technologies, by Mr Amook Vandan Yadav , Phone Number 8090848585 , Varanasi 



Comments