" NEIGH " - It Wasn't " TOTALLY " Nehru But " GANDHI - PATEL " That Drove Netaji Subash Out Of " CONGRESS " And India



Pic - :: The Horse " NEIGH "  sometime Is Far More Dangerous Than The " SILENT " oF A Lion Or A       " ROAR " Of The " TIGER "

NEIGH  - It Wasn't   TOTALLY  Nehru But  GANDHI - PATEL  That Drove Netaji Subash Out Of   CONGRESS  And India

NO - it should not be. Never that it should be. A person may be good bad or ugly, however there is some element of the same person having and holding some good traits and that should not be overlooked and the same person may not be counted down for the same.

 IS NEHRU RESPONSIBLE FOR EVERY ONSLAUGHT THAT INDIA HAS RECEIVED THROUGH ITS CONTEMPORARY.

Whenever it boils down to the old issues of our country, and whenever there are some instances of the NEFARICIOUS  incidents that occurs for an debate then the one who is always put on the BOILING HOT OR THE FRYING PAN is Mr Nehru for every reason. HOWEVER THE QUESTION IS – IS NEHRU THE ONE WHO HAS BEEN RESPONSIBLE FOR EVERY ONSLAUGHT THAT INDIA HAS RECEIVED THROUGH ITS CONTEMPORARY.

Nehru was an  ENIGMA or might have been a  MISNOMER  . He might have been a Hindu or a Muslim , by origin and that is again a debatable question. However ONE point that one might have to agree is NEHRU WAS NEVER BY ONE HUNDRED PERCENT AGAINST NETAJI BOSE FOR EVERYTHING OR EVERY REASON.

 WAS IT NEHRU WHO DROVE NETAJI OUT OF THE CONGRESS

A question that always haunts the Indian and India is  was Nehru the one who drove netaji out of the congress ?. This might appear to be a  QUESTION OF CONJECTURE ?.But the  STRAIGHT answer is  - NO. Both Nehru and Subash Netaji were very different on many an issue and many a points , but both after a  STRONG argument on points agreed if there was  POINT TO AGREE. Both were anti – pods to each other in thoughts but both understood each other well and agreed if there was a point to agree.  HOWEVER IT WAS NEHRU WHO DECLARED UPON THE FORCE APPLIED  BY THE BRITISH TO DECLATE NETAJI SUBASH AS THE TRAITOR AND A TERRORIST OF THE NATION INDIA. That was a SIN that Nehru did for which he would not be pardoned and that is the focal point of difference between India and her thoughts for Netaji Subash and Nehru.

It wasn’t Nehru who was responsible for driving Subash out of the Congress and out of India. Then who was it.  It might surprise  ONE AND SUNDRY – IT WAS SARDAR PATEL AND MAHATMA GANDHI.

THE RIFT BETWEEN PATEL AND SUBASH BABU - ::

This rift started when Netaji within the Congress defeated the candidate of Mahatma Gandhi, Shri Sitaramaiah Pattabhiraman by an overwhelming margin, and it was a  SETBACK for Sardar Patel as he was working on the ground , on the insistence of Gandhiji to make the win possible for Pattabhiramanji. This defeat was a cracking setback on the strength of Sardar Patel and he within himself was very upset about this. WHAT WAS MORE – ALL THE 19 MEMBERS FROM GUJARAT WHO WERE IN THE CONGRESS PARTY VOTED FOR SUBASH. These 19 members were brought in to the Congress by Patel and they were solid members of the Congress from Gujarat.

This had broke Patel by heart and he was against Subash from then. Thereafter Netaji to exercise his influence on the Congress so that he could unite them and solidify them as CONCRETE had requested 


Pic - ::  With His Left  Hand On The Leg Of Mahatma Gandhi And With The Duo In A Cosy Room Of The Yerwada Jail, Whenever This " GUJRATI " Duo Met At These Kind Of A Cosy Atmosphere, Only The " DANGEROUS " Outcome " CAME " Out For The Congress And " INDIA "

Gandhiji to give him more power within the party and in this affair he was seconded by Mr Gobind Vallabh Pant  and Mr Madan Mohan Malviya.

The relations between Nehru and Bose - ::

 The relation between Bose , Netaji and Jawahar Nehru continued to be cordial even after the latter was re-elected the Congress President in 1939 by defeating Pattabhi Sitaramaiah, the nominee of Mahatma Gandhi, in a straight contest. When differences arose between the Mahatma and Subhas on the constitution of the ‘Cabinet’ as the Congress Working Committee (CWC) was then called, the latter sought Jawaharlal’s advice and wrote to him on April 15, 1939: “Will it be possible for you to run up here for a few hours? We could then have a talk and I could have your advice as to how to proceed next?”

Jawaharlal not only travelled from Allahabad to Manbhum in Bihar to meet Bose, who was bed ridden, but also wrote to Gandhi on April 17: “I think now, as I thought in Delhi, that you should accept Subhas as president. To try and push him out seems to be an exceedingly wrong step.” But despite Jawaharlal’s best efforts the differences between the Mahatma and Subhas could not be sorted out. “ It had become extremely difficult for Gandhi, in the circumstances of the time, to reject the advice of his other colleagues in the right wing, led by " Patel ", who were determined not to compromise with Bose ”.

IT WAS HERE THAT SARDAR PATEL OPPOSED SUBASH AND INFLUENCED MAHATMA TO SUPRESS SUBASH.

It was here that Mahatma , courtesy Sardar Patel started ignoring, and suppressing Netaji Subash. Infact Mr Patel wwent on to say Mahatma Gandhi that SUBASH WAS A DICTATOR AND IF GIVEN A CHANCE TO LEAD INDIA HE WOULD CONVERT INDIA INTO A COUNTRY RULED BY DICTATOR . HE ADVOCATED SUBASH AS THE HITLER OF INIDIA IN HIS THOUGHT PROCESS.

Pic - : His Left Leg Pointed And Directed Toward Nehru And Nehrus Left Hand On It With Pattabhiraman Sitaramaiah Behind Reading A Note ,There Were Many Congreesite's Then Who Received BLESSINGS From Gandhiji, After Touching His Feet, Then , To Be In The " HELMS " Of The Congress 

Subash was a different element altogether. Like many of the Congressite he would NOT touch the feet of  Bapuji and would not put his legs on his LAP to run his hands over his legs or feet and would massage it or press it. Many in the Congress did that to receive the BEST of the BLESSINGS from Gandhiji  BUT NETAJI SUBASH NEVER. This was again a BONE OF CONTENTION, that was viewed as A egoist OF Subash and that was never liked by the LEFT-RIGHT hands of Mahatma  Gandhi . These left- right hands were the ones who were the “PRADHAN SEWAK ” of Gandhiji in the Congress , ironically ONE of them was Mr Sitaramaiah as depicted in the picture.

It was some public addressing by Netaji at Madras, then, at some part of Andhra , now and in some part of Lahore and Pakistan where the crowd that came in to hear Netaji and the mass that CONGEGERATED that completely shook the trio of NEHRU- PATEL – AND GANDHIJI and it was then and there that Gandhiji decided to hoof out Subash from the Congress on the insistence of Sardar Patel. 

Pic - :: A MAMMOTH crowd of Punjabi, Muslims and the Hindu students at the Lahore Railway Station on April 1929, receiving Subash Bose Sahab at the railway station at Lahore 

WHAT UPRROTED GANDHIJI AND PATEL TO DRIVE OUT NETAJI

The story is such and this. This is a fact and a truth that cannot be hidden anymore. Subash was getting  “ CLOSE, CLOSER AND CLOSEST ” to Jinnah and Jinnah who would “ NOT ” listen to the trio of Gandhi, Nehru and Patel at all. He  would “ TOE ” in to Subash to listen to him and agree to all that he would have to say to him, ie ,  Jinnah.

This completely uprooted the trio and though Nehru was not DETTERED much, Sardar and Mahatma could not bear this. Later on the insistence of Jinnah, where Jinnah had advised Netaji to speak to the Muslim, Hindu and the Punjabi youths at Lahore, Netaji reached Lahore of April 28th 1929 and delivered a speech, the next day ,  to the youths of Lahore especially to the Sikhs, Muslims and the Hindus.

Before that it is worth mentioning that Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose visited Lahore multiple times throughout his political career. Notably, he gave a speech titled "Towards Complete Independence" at the Lahore session of the Indian National Congress (INC) in 1929. Additionally, there is a photo of Netaji at Lahore City railway station dated November 24, 1938. He also escaped from his house arrest in January 1941 and passed through Amritsar on his way to Russia, halting briefly in Lahore. 

Pic - :: Mr Vitthal Bhai Patel And Mr Netaji Subash Chandra Bose At Vienna  When The Former Was About To Breathe His Last 

It was at Lahore,  A SIGHT TO BE HOLD  The ground where he delivered his speech addressing a massive crowd of over 1,00,000 PLUS of the public was SPEECHLESS AND MOTIONLESS to hear him AND IT WAS A PIN DROP SILENT there to hear him for over NINTY minutes . This was not taken in a positive manner by Pattaraman Sahab and Sardar Patel and they complaint about it to the Mahatma . Back from his sojourn at India, Mahatma Gandhi called him and said that HE WAS THE STORMY PETREL POSSESSING A WORST CHARACTER OF A CHILD WHO WAS DISMANTLING CONGRESS AND HE ORFDERD HIM TO LEAVE CONGRESS.

This is the actual story of the Netaji and his end of his rein as the CHIEF OF THE CONGRESS. Netaji took the permission from Gandhiji to finish certain official job of the Congress that was needed for him to expedite but that also  DID NOT GET THE APPROVAL of the Mahatma as Netaji was soon out of the ZONE and the PARTY of the Congress

VITTHAL BHAI PATEL MEETS NETAJI AT VIENNA AND HE DESERTS THE CONGRESS - ::

Way back between 1942 and 1943 the elder brother of Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel , Mr Vitthal Bhai Patel met Netaji at Vienna. Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel's elder brother was named Vitthalbhai Patel. He was a prominent figure in the Indian independence movement and served as the President (Speaker) of the Central Legislative Assembly in 1925. 

After meeting Netaji and looking into the way he was marching ahead withhis plan to liberate India from the clutches of the British HE DID AWAY WITH EVERYTHINGTHAT HE WAS DOING FOR CONGRESS.

From moves to moves and from work to work to expedite the job of Netaji, he worked tirelessly to help Netaji to expeditehis job very fast to counter the British. However he had a  FAILING  health which he could not conquer. While before he could breathe his last , he has about Rs 73 lakhs with him which he gave it to Netaji to use it for his mission. Netaji by that time had amassed Rs 73 CRORES as the reserve fund to use it for his fight, to pump it on the  AZAD HIND FAUJ to combat the British.

 SARDAR PATEL FILES A COURT CASE ON NETAJI  - ::

The news of the Rs 73 Lakha that Netaji had received from Vitthal Bhai had somehow reached Sardar Patel. Hearing to that and after assuring himself, Sardar Patel filed a court case against Netaji in the court of Vienna and also in the court of Switzerland and got the case transferred to the court at Bombay then.

He charged Netaji that he had brainwashed his eleder brother, first, to force him to leave the Congress and thereafter he played on his emotion to collect that amount of Rs 73 lakhs to put it under his belt for his  NEFARICIOUS  act against the BRITISH INDIA.

NETAJI SOBERLY AND POLITELY COUNTERS SARDAR PATEL-

Before taking on Sardar Patel on this issue, Netaji wrote him a POLITE letter addressing him the entire situation and then MADE IT CLEAR THAT HE BEING AN ADVOCATE AND A BAR – AT – LAW passed with DISTINCTION from England, HE WOULD SEE TO IT THAT THE COURT CASE REACHES THE END OF IT WITH SARDAR AND THE CONGRESS UPROOTED IN THIS CASE

This would cause the Congress a kind of a setback from where they would NOT recover at all. Hence that would have  DEMOLISHED the entire CREAMS and the COLOURS of the Congress requesting the Sardar to take the case back.

Upon the insistence of Mahatma Gandhi and some personal advise by Pandit Nehru , the Sardar took the case back and  NETAJI THROUGH HIS AZAD HIND FAUJ, A MUSLIM BY THE NAME OF KHAN ABDUL HAMID, RETURNED THE ENTIRE MONEY OF Rs SEVENTY THREE LAKHS to Sardar Patel.

 NEVER TO BECOME A CONGRESSITE AND NEVER TO SUPPORT THE CONGRESS – ::

This article is written NOT to support, either the GANDHI family or the Congress. My  HATE for the Congress was there, will be there and would always be there.

 “ MY HATE FOR THE CONGRESS WOULD BE LIKE THE HATE OF THE SNAKE FOR THE MONGOOSE OR THE HATE OF THE RAT FOR THE CAT ”.

We have a bad habit to always put every blame on the Gandhis and the Nehrus. However for some principal reason for some of her characteristics I LOVE MADAM GANDHI for her decision, some of them , for India. That is as an individual.

In the same manner there are certain anecdotes and notes, where we ought to RESPECT and give some mark to the Nehruji who was the Father of Madam Indira Gandhi.

 THIS ARTICLE IS JUST TO HIGHLIGHT ALL ABOUT THE WAR THAT WAS WITHIN THE CONGRESS BETWEEN SARDAR PATEL AND NETAJI BOSE WITH MAHATMA GANDHI ADDING THE FUEL TO THE FIRE.

HISTORY HAS A BAD HABIT OF REPEATING ITSELF - ::

The combination, and the DUO of Gandhi and Sardar Patel had done what could not be still  CORRECTED, even now in terms of the damage that it caused to India. That was the GUJRATI  DUO then.

 HOPE HISTORY DOES NOT REPEATS AGAIN THE WAY IT DID IT WHEN WE WERE THE SLAVES OF THE BRITISH.

 “ HIS -  STORY ” AND THE “ HISTORY ” HAS A BAD HABIT TO REPEAT AS  A      “ STOREY ”  FOR ITSELF  AS A “ STORY ”, AND AGAIN A REPETITION WILL COMPLETELY FINISH THE NATION.

 Last but not the least - a little bit of admiration, too, ought to be showered to Pandit Nehru at times,  though NOT always. 

 That Is It and that speaks all about it 

.Regards and Thanks

Pics



Mr Shyamal Bhattacharjee, the author was born at West Chirimiri Colliery at District Surguja, Chattisgarh on July 6th 1959 He received his early education at Carmel Convent School Bishrampur and later at Christ Church Boys' Higher Secondary School at Jabalpur. He later joined Hislop College at Nagpur and completed his graduation in Science and he also added a degree in  B A thereafter. He joined the HITAVADA, a leading dailies of Central India at Nagpur as a      Sub-Editor ( Sports ) but gave up to complete his MBA in 1984 He thereafter added a Diploma In Export Management. He has authored SEVEN   books namely Notable Quotes and Noble Thought published by Pustak Mahal in 2001 Indian Cricket : Faces That Changed It  published by Manas Publications in 2009 and Essential Of Office Management published by NBCA, Kolkatta  in 2012, GOLDEN QUOTES on INSPIRATION , SORROW , PEACE and LIFE published by B.F.C Publications, Lucknow, , and QUOTES:: Evolution and Origin of Management Electives by Clever Fox Publishing, Chennai ,From Dhyan To Dhan :: Indian Hockey - Sudden Death Or Extra Time published by   BOOKS CLINIC  Publishing House , Bilaspur , Chattisgarh and his FIRST book on Hindi poem, which reads as        " BHED HAI GEHRA - BAAT JARA SI   and  MIDAS TOUCH AND MIRACLES OF INDIAN SPORTS published by Books Clinics , Bilaspur , Chhattisgarh,  

He has a experience of about 35 years in Marketing , and Business Analytics .

 

 

 

Comments